U.S. Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania is pushing back against a recent New York Magazine article that raises questions about his mental fitness, labeling it a “hit piece”. The article, published May 2, 2025, features anonymous accounts from former and current staffers who express concerns about his health and behavior since his stroke in May 2022.
Staffers’ Concerns
The New York Magazine article paints a picture of an erratic senator who has become difficult to work for. Staffers, described as “his truest believers,” are now reportedly questioning his ability to serve in the Senate. Their worries extend beyond the Democratic Party to Fetterman’s well-being.
Specific concerns raised in the article include:
- Erratic behavior and mood swings: Staffers described Fetterman exhibiting mood swings and moments of paranoia.
- Failure to adhere to his recovery plan: There are claims that Fetterman has not been consistent with his post-stroke treatment, including skipping regular blood draws.
- Reckless behavior: His former chief of staff, Adam Jentleson, noted instances of reckless driving and the purchase of a gun, though Fetterman stated he takes necessary firearm precautions.
- Strained relationships: The article suggests Fetterman’s behavior has created tension with his wife, Gisele, and his colleagues.
- Concerns about medication: Jentleson reportedly wrote an email expressing doubts about Fetterman taking his medication, observing “conspiratorial thinking,” “megalomania,” and rambling.
Fetterman’s Response
Fetterman has dismissed the concerns as “absolute false things” and a “one-source hit piece” from a left-leaning publication. He insists he is following his doctors’ prescribed plan and that his health issues are limited to the depression he has previously discussed publicly.
Key points from Fetterman’s defense:
- Denial of new mental health problems: Fetterman stated that it is “outrageous” to suggest he has mental health problems beyond his previously disclosed depression, with his doctors allegedly confirming this.
- Adherence to treatment: He claims to be adhering to a strict program designed by his doctors.
- Dismissal of reckless behavior: Fetterman has denied the claims of reckless and erratic behavior.
- Vow to serve full term: He has stated he will serve his full term in the Senate.
Background: Stroke and Depression
John Fetterman’s health has been a topic of public discussion since he suffered a stroke in May 2022, just days before winning the Democratic primary for Pennsylvania’s Senate seat. The stroke left him with auditory processing issues, which he manages with technology that transcribes what people are saying in real-time. During his campaign against Republican Mehmet Oz, Fetterman’s health became a significant point of contention.
In early 2023, Fetterman spent six weeks at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for treatment of clinical depression. He has been open about his struggles with depression, stating that his Senate race negatively impacted his mental health.
The Timeline of Events
- May 2022: Fetterman suffers a stroke.
- November 2022: Despite health concerns, Fetterman defeats Mehmet Oz in the Senate election.
- January 2023: Fetterman is sworn into office.
- February 2023: Fetterman admits himself to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for treatment of clinical depression.
- March 2023: Fetterman is discharged from Walter Reed with a recovery plan.
- May 2024: Adam Jentleson, Fetterman’s then-chief of staff, sends an email to the medical director at Walter Reed expressing concerns about Fetterman’s health.
- March 2024: Adam Jentleson departs Fetterman’s team.
- May 2025: New York Magazine publishes an article detailing concerns about Fetterman’s mental fitness based on accounts from former and current staffers.
- May 2025: Fetterman responds to the article, calling it a “hit piece” and denying the allegations.
Reactions and Implications
The New York Magazine article has sparked a range of reactions, from concern to outright dismissal. Some conservative commentators suggest the criticism stems from Fetterman’s support of Israel, while others point to his willingness to work with the Trump administration.
The implications of these allegations are significant. They raise questions about Fetterman’s ability to effectively represent his constituents and fulfill his duties as a senator. The controversy also highlights the challenges individuals face when navigating mental health issues in the public eye.
Fetterman’s Auditory Processing Issues
Following his stroke, Fetterman has had to adapt to auditory processing issues. This condition makes it difficult for him to understand spoken language, requiring him to use assistive technology.
Use of Assistive Technology
To address his auditory processing challenges, Fetterman uses a live caption display monitor at his desk in the Senate chamber. This technology allows him to read captions of what is being said in real-time, ensuring he can fully participate in Senate proceedings.
Senate Chamber Adaptations
The Senate has made accommodations to support Fetterman’s recovery. The Sergeant at Arms installed the caption display monitor at his desk, and colleagues have been understanding and supportive as he navigates his new role with the help of technology.
Impact on Communication
While the auditory processing issues are sometimes invisible, Fetterman relies on the assistive technology to communicate effectively. During votes and meetings, he can exchange words with other lawmakers, but the captioning ensures he doesn’t miss any critical information.
The Role of Adam Jentleson
Adam Jentleson, Fetterman’s former chief of staff, is a key figure in the controversy. His concerns about Fetterman’s health, detailed in an email to the medical director at Walter Reed, form a significant part of the New York Magazine article.
Jentleson’s Concerns
Jentleson’s email outlined several “warning signs” he observed in Fetterman’s behavior, including “conspiratorial thinking,” “megalomania,” and a failure to adhere to his recovery plan. He expressed worry about Fetterman’s trajectory and questioned whether he was taking his medication.
Jentleson’s Motives
Fetterman has suggested that Jentleson has a “weird grudge” and an “agenda”. He questioned why, if Jentleson were genuinely concerned, he would go to the media instead of addressing the issues privately.
Differing Perspectives
While Jentleson’s concerns paint a dire picture of Fetterman’s health, the senator insists that he is doing well and following his doctor’s advice. This discrepancy raises questions about the accuracy and completeness of the information presented in the New York Magazine article.
Mental Health in the Public Eye
Fetterman’s situation underscores the challenges individuals face when dealing with mental health issues in the public sphere. The scrutiny and pressure of public office can exacerbate existing conditions and create new obstacles to recovery.
Stigma and Misconceptions
Mental health often carries a stigma that can prevent people from seeking help or being open about their struggles. Misconceptions about mental illness can also lead to unfair judgments and discrimination.
The Importance of Support
Fetterman’s case highlights the importance of support systems for individuals with mental health challenges. Access to quality medical care, understanding colleagues, and supportive family and friends can all play a crucial role in recovery.
Navigating Public Life
For public figures like Fetterman, navigating mental health issues requires a delicate balance between transparency and privacy. Sharing personal experiences can help reduce stigma and encourage others to seek help, but it can also open the door to unwanted scrutiny and criticism.
The Road Ahead
As John Fetterman continues to serve in the Senate, the questions surrounding his health and fitness are likely to persist. Whether he can successfully address these concerns and regain the trust of his constituents remains to be seen.
